During landing gear maintenance, technicians remove components, clean and inspect them, and measure their dimensions. They grind away minor damage where repair limits permit. If too much material has been lost, replacement is often the only option. This increases costs, extends aircraft downtime and consumes resources.
Hard chromium plating traditionally protects functional surfaces against wear and corrosion. Stricter environmental and occupational safety requirements, however, are increasing the need for alternatives. Protection alone is not enough for damaged areas: A repair process must also restore lost material precisely without compromising the properties of the high-strength base material.
Conventional welding processes are only partly suitable for this task. Excessive heat can alter the microstructure of high-strength aerospace steels, affect their mechanical properties and cause distortion that changes component geometry. The heat-affected zone is particularly critical. A suitable repair process must, therefore, form a reliable metallurgical bond while limiting heat input.
LEGATO develops a new repair process chain
The LEGATO research project addresses this challenge. The broader project investigates several aspects of future landing gear systems, bringing together expertise from industry and research. As part of this effort, the Fraunhofer Institute for Laser Technology ILT is developing a laser-based repair process chain for heavily loaded landing gear components.
“Our research focuses on three steps,” says Kim Julia Kallies, project manager at Fraunhofer ILT. “Restoring material locally, tailoring the mechanical properties of the surface layer, and reliably inspecting the resulting coating.”
Industry partner Liebherr-Aerospace is contributing practical requirements from manufacturing, maintenance, and repair: actual components and damage patterns, as well as specifications regarding materials, hardness, surface quality, and low heat input. The associated partner, Hegenscheidt-MFD, is assisting the project with its expertise in roller burnishing and deep rolling processes.
“Ultimately, it is not enough for a coating to perform well in the laboratory,” explains Harald Betsch of Liebherr-Aerospace, Senior Expert Thermal Spraying/Welding in Materials and Processes. “What matters is whether the process is suitable for real landing gear components under load, including their materials, damage patterns and repair limits. These are precisely the requirements we bring to LEGATO from development, manufacturing and maintenance.”
EHLA deposits the material. This high-speed variant of laser metal deposition (LMD) uses a laser to melt metallic powder and deposit it locally on the component surface. EHLA’s high processing speed and relatively low heat input make it particularly promising for heat-sensitive, high-strength materials.
For the project, Kim Kallies and her research group are investigating several material combinations relevant to the application. For example, the team has repaired 300M steel using matching material. For corrosion-resistant coatings, they are testing a martensitic stainless steel developed specifically for EHLA, among other materials. The researchers are also studying 15-5PH, a high-strength, corrosion-resistant steel used in landing gear structures.
One special characteristic of EHLA leads directly to the next step: Its processing speeds are much closer to those of mechanical machining processes than conventional LMD speeds are. This allows the team to combine material deposition directly with mechanical finishing—the approach behind SCaRB.
EHLA and roller burnishing in a single process
SCaRB stands for Simultaneous Coating and Roller Burnishing. It combines EHLA deposition with roller burnishing immediately afterward. As the laser deposits metallic powder onto the component surface, a burnishing tool follows at a defined distance, working the newly deposited layer while coating process is still underway.
EHLA’s high processing speed makes this combination possible: Deposition and burnishing take place in a single process sequence. The team does not need to re-clamp the component between coating and mechanical finishing, thereby reducing setup time and taking advantage of the short interval between the two steps.
SCaRB does not only take advantage of EHLA’s speed, but also of its residual heat. Shortly after deposition, the new layer is still warm and, therefore, easier to deform plastically. The distance between the laser and burnishing tool determines how warm and deformable the layer remains when the tool reaches it. This distance helps control surface characteristics, hardness and residual stresses.
Hegenscheidt-MFD has developed a burnishing tool for the process, which Fraunhofer ILT integrated into the machine. The team adjusts the burnishing force by changing the tool’s feed rate and uses interchangeable rollers to select the radius and hardness appropriate for each application.
“The key for us is to use the layer while it is still warm, rather than finishing the EHLA coating in a separate operation afterward,” explains the project manager. “Roller burnishing smooths the surface while also affecting hardness and residual stresses. SCaRB therefore turns material deposition into a process that lets us tailor the repaired area to its intended function.”